By the time you arrive at the end of
Ken Burns and Lynn Novick's staggering 10-part and 18-hour documentary,
The Vietnam War, you may feel so emotionally devastated by the experience that you won't find it easy to sum up its impact. Nevertheless, many on the left and right have already attempted to do so. They seem to share common ground in their belief that the series, in its desire to capture the war from all sides, cancels out any strong subjective opinion of it. From the left, you get the impression that they lament the absence of Noam Chomsky, as if Burns and Novick didn't go far enough in their condemnation of America's war policy. As for the right, there is a discomfort that if only William F. Buckley were still around he'd be able to put those liberal intellectuals in their place and we wouldn't be seeing so many North Vietnamese soldiers drawing moral equivalences with the American experience. Yet one thing is certain in all this contentious debate: the Vietnam War continues to divide and polarize Americans to the extent that maybe
no film could fully heal the breach.
The Vietnam War, with all its flaws and virtues, goes further than any other documentary toward mapping out its tragic course, clarifying the poor policy decisions that needlessly cost altogether millions of lives, and illuminating the traumatic experiences of those who fought in it. Unlike many of the confused attempts by dramatic films as varied as
The Deer Hunter,
Apocalypse Now and
Full Metal Jacket to definitively define the conflict,
The Vietnam War delves right into the political hubris that created the war rather than rendering it mystical (
Apocalypse Now), turning it into a rites-of-passage parable (
The Deer Hunter), or reducing the specifics of war trauma to systemic and sadistic conditioning (
Full Metal Jacket). At its best,
The Vietnam War fully
lays out what Burns calls in a recent profile in
The New Yorker his "emotional archaeology" so that viewers can come to their own conclusions. But its flaws, some of which grow out of that need to be fair and even-handed, also reveal an unvarying tone which – over such a long stretch – overwhelms the senses.