|
Rebecca Naomi Jones and Damon Daunno in Oklahoma!. (Photo: Teddy Wolff) |
Daniel Fish’s new, stripped-down production of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s
Oklahoma!, which has moved from St. Ann’s Warehouse to Broadway’s
Circle in the Square Theatre, is being hailed as brilliant and
revolutionary, much like the original 1943 version, even though that didn’t
do anything that the 1927 Kern and Hammerstein
Show Boat (or for
that matter, the 1940 Rodgers and Hart
Pal Joey), hadn’t done
before and better.
Revolutionary? Let’s start at the end: in this
Oklahoma!, after
the cast has sung the title song, our heroes, the bronco-buster Curly
(played by Damon Daunno, so slight he looks like he’d split in two if he ever
sat astride a horse) and Laurey (a very angry Rebecca Naomi Jones) are
dressed in white for their wedding, when Jud Fry (Patrick Vaill) crashes in
and offers Curly a gift, conditional upon his getting to kiss the bride.
Jud and Laurey French-kiss, despite Jud's having previously tried to rape her and
threatened her and her family. Curly opens the gift, and it’s a gun (not
the booby-trapped “Little Wonder” traditional to stodgy stagings of yore).
Jud then stands about ten feet in front of Curley and spreads his arms.
Curly shoots him. Curly’s gun is rigged so that Curly (yes,
Curly)
is spattered with copious amounts of blood, his face crimson and dripping,
his white (modern-dress) cowboy suit now mostly red, with a significant
portion of blood spattering his bride. Jud is still standing. The rest of
the eleven-person cast, who have been sitting around in chairs watching
this, intone the next four or five minutes of dialogue with no affect. “Is
he dead? He looks dead.” (Uh, he’s still standing, so no, he isn’t dead.)
After too much of this, Judd goes upstage and lies down on the floor. Aunt
Eller (the redoubtable Mary Testa) then bullies the local marshal and judge
into a kangaroo-court trial that finds Curly innocent by reason of
self-defense; the ensemble reprises the title tune; and as they sing of the
grandness of the land they belong to and the new union they hope to join,
Laurey sobs in sorrow, others writhe in misery, some stomp in anger, and
Curly plays the guitar in his blood-stained clothes. All is corrupt, all is
unclean, all is rot.
Wait, what?